Veranstaltungen
 
Metagora Partners Group I
Bamako - Workshop on surveys
Task Team on pilot surveys
Metagora Partners Group II
Metagora Forum

Metagora Forum

Presenting and discussing first results

Reference documents

The Metagora Forum was held on 24-25 May 2005. It was an informal policy-oriented meeting aimed at:

  • confronting the development and findings of Metagora with the effective needs of the stakeholders in the field of monitoring democracy, human rights and governance;
  • providing guidance and advice for strengthening the policy incidence of the project's process and outcomes;
  • fostering interaction and synergies between Metagora and other similar projects and initiatives;
  • formulating proposals to integrate specific Metagora achievements and findings within existing or planned monitoring mechanisms;
  • formulating orientations and proposals for a follow-up to Metagora achievements after the end of the pilot phase.

The Forum was attended by some 130 participants including :
i) major relevant actors and stakeholders in the field of monitoring democracy, human rights and governance;
ii) representatives of some 30 national and international governmental and non-governmental organizations that are involved or strongly interested in the project;
iii) current and potential Metagora donors;
iv) Metagora partner organizations (PIOs) and associated experts;
v) selected members of DAC, GOVNET and PARIS21 Consortium.

The Forum allowed stakeholders to comment on significant lessons, such as the complementary role of statistical methods in the work of Human Rights Institutions as well as the empowerment impact of these methods in the research and advocacy work of civil society’s organizations. Attendants to the Forum commented on promising outcomes from a tentative assessment of national governance indicators compiled by different institutions in the same countries. Finally the debates of the Forum showed that the bottom-up approach to national indicators merits enhancement in order to complement and enrich the top-down approach that underlies the production of international aggregate governance indicators.

Final agenda of the Forum


TUESDAY, 24 May 2005, Morning

Chair: Mr. Jean-Louis Bodin, former President of the International Statistical Institute and Chairman of the Metagora Independent Panel of Experts

08:00 - 09:00 Registration
09:00 - 09:30 Opening session
09:00 - 09:10
  • Welcome address by Mr. Richard Manning, Chairman of the OECD Development Assistance Committee (DAC)
09:10 - 09:20
  • Introductory remarks on the Forum's background and objectives, by Dr. Mark Orkin, CEO, Human Sciences Research Council of South Africa, and Chairman of the Metagora Partner's Group (by video-conference)
09:20 - 09:30
  • The Metagora Community and beyond: the need for an inclusive Forum, by Mr. Raul Suarez de Miguel, Metagora general co-ordinator
09:30 - 13:00 Session I: Presentation of Metagora preliminary findings and outcomes
09:30 - 10:00
10:00 - 10:15
  • Recording and transmitting lessons and good practices for measuring democracy, human rights and governance (DHRG): a prototype tool for making available relevant training materials, by Mrs. Jana Asher, StatAid (USA), head of the Metagora Task Team on Training Materials
10:15 - 10:30
11:00 - 11:15
  • Discussant 1: Focusing on the objective: to increase knowledge and capacities for monitoring effective implementation of human rights and democracy, by Mr. Michel Tubiana, Vice-President of the International Federation of Human Rights Leagues and President of the French League for Human Rights (France).
11:15 - 11:30
  • Discussant 2: Improving evidence-based reporting on DHRG issues: the Project's strengths, weaknesses and perspectives, by Prof. Stephen E. Fienberg, Carnegie Mellon (USA)
11:30 - 11:45
  • Discussant 3: Enhancing policy orientation: challenges and perspectives opened up by Metagora, by Mr. Emilio Álvarez Icaza Longoria, Chairman of the Commission for Human Rights of Mexico City (Federal District)
11:45 - 12:45
  • General discussion
12:45 - 13:00
  • Summary of comments of the Independent Panel of Experts on the Project's progress, and conclusions of the session by the Chair

TUESDAY, 24 May 2005, Afternoon

Chair: Atty. Dr. Purificacion Valera Quisumbing, Chairperson, Commission on Human Rights of the Philippines

14:30 - 16:20 Session II: Selected examples of measuring DHRG
14:30 - 14:50
14:50 - 15:10
15:10 - 15:30
  • Experiences and perspectives on collecting and analyzing human rights data during conflict situations, by Dr. Peggy Jennings and Dr. Shana Swiss, Women's Rights International, USA
15:30 - 16:00 Discussants: can these kinds of monitoring approaches enhance or enrich the work and outcomes of human rights institutions and non-governmental organizations?
  • Discussant 1: Mr. Romesh Silva, Metagora Associated Expert
  • Discussant 2: Mr. Narandran Kollapen, Commissioner, South Africa Human Rights Commission
  • Discussant 3: Dr. Susannah Sirkin, Deputy Director, Physicians for Human Rights
16:00 - 16:20
  • General Discussion
16:20 - 16:40 Coffee break
16:40 - 18:00 Session III: Complementary top-down / bottom-up approaches on measuring DHRG: the example of the rights of the child
16:40 - 17:10
17:10 - 17:20
17:20 - 18:00
  • General discussion
  • Conclusions by the Chair

WEDNESDAY, 25 May 2005, Morning

Chair: Mr. Antoine Simonpietri, Manager of PARIS21, OECD

09:00 - 09:30 Keynote Address:
Policy-oriented indicators: What kind of information do policy makers need to promote and enhance democracy and good governance?

By Ambassador Allan Wagner, Secretary General of the Andean Community
09:30 - 11:50 Session IV: Bottom-up approach to governance indicators
09:30 - 10:10
  • Using official household surveys to build policy-oriented indicators on democracy and governance, by Dr. Javier Herrera, Dr. Mireille Razafindrakoto, Dr. François Roubaud, DIAL (France)
10:10 - 10:30
10:30 - 10:50
10:50 - 11:20 Coffee break
11:20 - 11:50
  • General discussion
11:50 - 13:00 Session V: Panel on the involvement of official statistics in measuring DHRG
Discussants:
  • Mr. Jean Razafindravonona, Director-General of the National Statistical Institute of Madagascar;
  • Mr. Loay Shabaneh, President of the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics, PCBS (Palestine)
  • Dr. Romulo Virola, Secretary-General of the National Statistical Co-ordination Board of the Philippines, NSCB (Philippines)
  • Mr. Guillermo Lecaros, Head of Statistics, General-Secretariat of the Andean Community;
  • Mr. Lamine Diop, former Director-General of AFRISTAT

WEDNESDAY, 25 May 2005, Afternoon

Chair: Mr. Miloon Kothari, UN Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing (India)

14:30 - 16:00 Session VI: Complementary top-down/bottom-up approaches to measuring economic and social rights: the example of the right to education
14:30 - 14:45
14:45 - 15:00
15:00 - 15:15
  • Complementarity of aggregate governance indicators and national policy-oriented governance indicators, by Mr. Daniel Kaufmann, Director Global Programs and Governance, World Bank Institute (by video-conference)
15:15 - 15:30
15:30 - 16:00
  • General discussion
16:00 - 16:30 Coffee break
16:30 - 18:00 Session VII: Enhancing synergies and strengthening Metagora objectives
Presentation of the outcomes and follow-up of:
16:30 - 16:40
  • Expert meeting on "human rights indicators" (Turku, Finland, 10-13 March 2005), convened by the Institute for Human Rights, Abo Academy University, in collaboration with the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights - by Dr. Rajeev Malhotra and Mr. Nicolas Fasel (OHCHR)
16:40 - 16:50
  • Workshop on "measuring impact in human rights: How far have we come, how far to go?" (Harvard, 5-7 May 2005), convened by the Carr Centre for Human Rights Policy, Kennedy School for Governance, Harvard University - by Ms. Eleanor I. Benko and Mr. Rory Stewart (Carr Centre)
16:50 - 17:00
17:00 - 17:45
  • General discussion about the main orientations emerging from the forum on:
    • i) the complementary approaches to measuring DHRG;
    • ii) interaction and synergies between relevant on-going initiatives;
    • iii) next steps of the Metagora working program;
    • iv) follow-up to Metagora achievements after the term of the pilot project.
17:45 - 18:00 Summary of conclusions and farewell
 
   
  top